Showing posts with label Egypt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Egypt. Show all posts

Monday, March 21, 2011

PD in the New Egypt

I found this article on The Huffington Post quite interesting. It outlines what needs to be done in order for the U.S. to rebuild its relationship with Egypt. This is intriguing because still in recent memory is the June 4, 2009 Cairo speech that Obama gave which promised a “new beginning” and there was much hope brought by his inspiring words not only to Egypt but to the Muslim world. Mutual respect and understanding were major points and there was promise that we were on the brink of a major breakthrough. However, this was not entirely case. Some strides have been made in improving the relationship but one sore spot was never addressed until the revolution, the fact that we had continued to support Mubarak in spite of his actions of oppressing his fellow Egyptians. This was a major contradiction between our words and our actions; the U.S. did not live up to their promises, which has put us in a harsh light.


U.S. PD in Egypt is having a credibility crisis because we have not followed through on our words, which makes our PD efforts ineffective, as the article states, “But it cannot do so as long as much of U.S. public diplomacy is seen by the rest of the world as self-serving propaganda”. This is a huge problem and it invalidates our PD efforts, we must be sincere and credible because without those aspects our PD will accomplish nothing. The article states that, “the philosophy of U.S. public diplomacy should be altered to put greater emphasis on service to the individuals around the world”. The U.S. must realign their PD efforts to match our promises because credibility makes all the difference.



Article Links:

Monday, February 7, 2011

U.S. Dialogue Shift...Soft Power Potential?

Yesterday, Secretary of State Hilary Clinton announced that the U.S. will stand behind the Egyptian people and give them support to guarantee their desires for free and fair elections and the other freedoms they have been deprived of. This is a dialogue switch from prior statements that were made by the U.S. government. Hilary stated that she wants to ensure a peaceful, smooth transition to a transparent government.


It seems that the U.S. has learned from past revolution disasters, such as the Iranian Revolution of 1979, which stemmed from discontentment with the U.S. backed Shah. Thus instead of backing Mubarak strongly, they are opting for a “new beginning”, which harkens back to Obama’s June 4th 2009 speech in Cairo, which promised a fresh start for U.S. relations with the Middle East and the Muslim world. Until now Obama has not kept the many promises he made in that speech, but now his words may be holding true.


The U.S. favors an orderly transition because it will give the government and people time to process the change, rather than a violent ousting of Mubarak, hence why the U.S. is softly urging him to start transitioning out of office. Alternatively a very slow transition in which Mubarak stays in power until September would not be ideal either because it would give the Muslim Brotherhood more time to gather support. In a Washington Post article Secretary of State Clinton stated that Egypt’s leadership should seek dialogue with the opposition, but as of yet no progress has been made on that front.


It will be interesting how the U.S. will handle this transition because Egypt has been an ally, but at the same time the Egyptian people have been cheated and deprived of their rights. Thus the U.S. cannot be too harsh in their dialogue, but they cannot be too weak because the people of Egypt are looking for support in their fight for freedom. To reference our class discussion about soft power last week, this is a prime opportunity for the U.S. to exercise our soft power. The Egyptian people want freedom and the U.S. has the opportunity to foster freedom and fair government within the nation. The U.S. has the potential to be a hero in this situation and exercise a fair amount of soft power but will the U.S. take the bait?


Links to the articles:

http://us.mobile.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE71175920110206?WT.tsrc=Social%20Media&ca=rdt


http://blogs.state.gov/index.php/site/entry/update_egypt


http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2011/02/05/AR2011020501707_3.html?wpisrc=nl_headline&sid=ST2011020402531